Meet your friends at the Club for Growth

If you’ve been watching TV lately, you’ve probably seen some ads placed by the Club for Growth. Never mind the points being made are moot, since public employee unions have already agreed that members will contribute more toward health insurance and their retirement fund. The Club for Growth had their ads on the air before some Wisconsin legislators even had a copy of Governor Walker’s “budget repair” bill in their hands:

* * *

“Like last Friday morning, when I was driving to a school business administrator’s meeting in De Pere. And I turned on the radio and there was an ad saying, “Hey, support Governor Walker’s Budget Repair Bill. Paid for by the Club of Growth.” Well guess what, I had never been given a bill… And it’s bad enough, it’s bad enough that I had to hear it from a radio ad from Washington DC, and then show up at a meeting with no details…”

– Rep. Gordon Hintz

* * *


The Club for Growth would like the people of Wisconsin to support Governor Walker’s union-busting bill, but it’s just fine with them if people don’t understand what’s in it and what it means. Their ads don’t deal with the issue on the table, which is collective bargaining. But those ads aren’t just for you. What they’re really about is trying to intimidate legislators and especially Republican senators, who might otherwise be tempted to vote their conscience and break ranks from the far-right party line being advanced by the guv.

You see, not everyone is in the club.

The Club for Growth has made a business not only of putting people in office, but bringing opposition in primary races against GOP legislators who they don’t think are adhering to their conservative doctrine. Ask Republican Lisa Murkowski of Alaska, who miraculously won a write-in campaign to keep her U.S. Senate seat last November. The Club for Growth tried to swing that seat to Joe Miller, (Sarah Palin’s pick in that race.) Some of us never cheered harder for a Republican Senator than we did for Murkowski.

They successfully unseated Republican Senator Bob Bennett of Utah in the 2010, replacing him with Mike Lee. They backed Marco Rubio in Florida, forcing Republican Governor Charlie Crist to run as an independent in the U.S. Senate race that Rubio ended up winning. Remember Senator Arlen Specter switching over to become a Democrat in Pennsylvania? His seat is now held by former Club for Growth President Pat Toomey. Remember Russ Feingold? The Club for Growth poured six figures into negative ads and their approved candidate, Ron Johnson, now holds the seat.

The Club for Growth was a player with Wisconsin Manufacturers and Commerce in the ridiculously negative Wisconsin Supreme Court races over the past few years and they are backing Justice Prosser this year.

And now the Club for Growth is blasting the airwaves in Wisconsin again, this time to protect their protégé governor Scott Walker that they supported heavily. All the while, they’re reminding everyone in the Republican ranks — including Scott Walker – that they’re ready to pour on the money against anyone who strays from their no-compromise, hard right party line. The Club for Growth would like to win, but they are just as interested in exacting punishment against wayward Republicans.

Here’s a little snippet from a Club for Growth mailing in 2006 to their members:

“Politicians are risk-adverse. Every Republican in Congress knows what we did in Rhode Island. They realize that Club members donated an incredible $725,000 to Chafee’s challenger. They know that the Club for Growth PAC spent an additional $515,000, mostly on TV ads, and took a challenger from being down 2 to 1 in the polls to the edge of an upset. As senators cast their votes on key bills, wavering Republicans will have to wonder if they could withstand the same punishment.”

* * *

You can thank the U.S. Supreme Court’s horrendous Citizens United decision for making this problem even worse now than it was in the past (and it was already plenty bad.)  

I’m providing a couple of pictures here. One is Steve Moore, founder of the Club for Growth. The other is Governor Scott Walker. Did you notice the background is the same? It’s no coincidence that they were both appearing on the agenda at an Americans for Prosperity event around two years ago in Milwaukee. It’s no coincidence that the Club for Growth holds hands with Koch Brothers funded groups. And it’s no coincidence that even though Wisconsin public employee unions have already given the governor everything he says he needs on the money side, he still won’t compromise.  The club doesn’t compromise and if you do, you’re not club material for anything but an assault in the next election cycle.

Trees are known by their fruit and people are known by the company they keep. 



3 Responses to “Meet your friends at the Club for Growth”

  1. DEMAND AN END TO THE CLUB FOR GROWTH ADS! Sample letter below.

    WAOW/WYOW Television
    1908 Grand Avenue
    Wausau, WI 54403 Dear WAOW TV 9, Many of your viewers are very concerned about dishonesty in ads run on your station since Feb. 20. Club for Growth ads are part of a campaign to influence voters to call their legislators in support of Assembly and Senate Bill 11, also known as the budget repair bill. The ad says ‘state workers have not had to sacrifice’ and wraps its arguments in coercive dishonesty.

    I value freedom of speech and agree that WAOW has the right to accept money to air the ad, and that the Club for Growth has the right to pay for this ad.

    However, this ad is ‘barely true’ as rated by the Milwaukee Journal-Sentinel Politifact column. I am concerned because this ad perpetuates misconceptions and divisiveness in our region and the state. By choosing to air this ad, WAOW is, in fact, taking a stand on this bill and supporting its sweeping negative effects on our state.

    The claim that the station is also airing AFL-CIO ads does not appease my concerns. I have yet to see any of those ads aired on your station during the same period of time when the Club for Growth ads were aired.
    Many of your viewers in the Central Wisconsin area share this concern. As a trusted news station you have a responsibility to contribute to truth and facts in the public dialogue. Prioritizing revenue which comes from a deceptive ad with extremely negative consequences ignores the public good. You are sending a clear message on where WAOW stands on this challenge to public worker rights and the public transit system.
    Please stop running the Club for Growth ad until the Club for Growth reworks the ad to replace deception with facts. If I do not receive notification from you, either personally, or through a public notification, my allies and I will begin contacting your local advertisers to inform them we will not be patronizing their businesses just as we will not be tuning into WAOW TV 9. You will find that many of these businesses have deep respect for Wisconsin’s tradition of labor rights and fair play.

  2. I’m certainly with you on respect for Wisconsin’s traditions and I share your distress at what the current GOP administration and legislative majorities seem willing to do — often at the behest of corporate interests.

    But I also have to say that as reprehensible as I find the Club for Growth and MANY of the political messages I see in campaigns from independent groups, I think it puts ANY media outlet in a bad position if they are charged with having to research and authenticate the claims being made. There are freedom of speech issues involved, too. I am far more concerned with CONTENT outside of advertising (such as the daily dose of dogma from WSAU 55 Radio, for example.

  3. […] yes, the Club for Growth is currently carpet-bombing the Wisconsin airwaves again, this time with ads backing the anti-worker stance of Scott Walker, Prosser’s fellow […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: